Judge Issues Order to Halt Activity at Downtown Jail Site; Lawsuit Alleges Illegal Plans for Round-the-Clock Construction
On Monday afternoon, October 26, a New York State Supreme Court judge issued a temporary restraining order to stop work at the site of the planned Manhattan Detention Complex (MDC) on Centre Street in the Civic Center district. The judge’s order was issued in response to a lawsuit filed October 12 by a coalition of Chinatown leaders, alleging that the administration of Mayor Zohran Mamdani is unlawfully implementing a construction schedule at the site that would run from 4am to midnight five days per week, with extra shifts on weekends.
The MDC site has been the focus of controversy for almost a decade, starting with the March 2017 announcement by then-Mayor Bill de Blasio that he intended to close the City’s centralized detention facility on Rikers Island, and replace it with four borough-based jails (one in each borough except Staten Island). At the time, the City envisioned shutting down Rikers and opening the four new facilities by 2027. The Manhattan site is slated to hold the world’s tallest detention facility.
Foundation work did not start at the Centre Street site until this year, however, and construction is now expected to continue through at least 2032. In an attempt to meet this deadline, City officials acknowledged in an October 6 presentation that they plan to allow work at the site for up to 20 hours per day.
The lawsuit that prompted Monday’s temporary restraining order argues that the new schedule contradicts the Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) that the City filed two years after Mr. de Blasio’s announcement, which originally represented the work schedule as being limited to the customary construction hours of 7am through 3:30pm, with occasional extensions to 6pm. The coalition that filed the suit asserts that the original EIS is legally binding, and that any significant departure from its terms creates the legal necessity for a new environmental review process. The group argues that the expanded schedule will impose unreasonable hardships on residents, businesses, and organizations situated adjacent to the MDC site, including a senior living facility, a daycare facility, medical offices, multiple family-owned retailer establishments, tenement apartments, a community media center, and a cinema.
“Today, a New York County Supreme Court judge validated what Chinatown has been saying for a long time,” said Vic Lee, chief executive officer of Welcome to Chinatown. “The City’s plans for years of nighttime drilling and overnight construction are dangerous to the surrounding community. We believe in closing Rikers, but its closure should not cause more marginalized communities to suffer. Our culture believes in honoring our elders. Subjecting them to around-the-clock drilling and construction through their final years is inhumane and cruel.”
“Our efforts to bring attention to the dangers and serious health effects of after-hours construction at the site of the world’s tallest jail have been recognized by a judge,”
said Jan Lee, founder of Neighbors United Below Canal. “We will continue to fight for our health and safety throughout this legal process. A third of our community lives below the poverty line, many in aging buildings just feet from this construction site. To impose nighttime drilling and the movement of 30-ton trucks through Chinatown’s narrow streets throughout the night is nothing less than inhumane. This is far more than an inconvenience. It is a threat to the health and well-being of an entire community.”
“For Chinatown’s elderly residents, the concern is not simply a jackhammer blast lasting a few seconds,” he added. “It is the cumulative impact of repeated, unpredictable disturbances, day after day and night after night, over years of construction. Years of peer-reviewed studies show that nighttime noise can interrupt restorative sleep and activate the body’s stress response, potentially contributing to elevated blood pressure and other health problems over time. This is not the plan that went through the City’s public review process in 2019. This plan could dismantle Chinatown.”
“We have already seen how the impacts caused by this new jail have begun to displace long-term residents and businesses in the heart of Chinatown,” said City Council member Christopher Marte. “Air pollution, vibration, and noise have destroyed the lives of seniors living just feet away from construction. This unilateral move to work overnight and on weekends serves as the latest example of the City’s prioritization of a mega-jail over the health and safety of New Yorkers. We will not allow this jail to succeed in erasing our community.”
Court documents filed as part of the October 22 suit allege, “for the next six-year, seven-month and 25-day period, the City and its contractor are planning to conduct construction activity at the Manhattan Jail site from 7am to 12am, Mondays through Fridays (two shifts per weekday) plus 9am to 5pm on Saturdays, plus deliveries from 4am to 7am.”
“No environmental review was conducted by the City to consider, let alone quantify, the potential environmental impacts arising from this new construction schedule,” the lawsuit contends, adding, “among the limited circumstances for which after hours work authorization may be granted are ‘emergency work’ for conditions involving threats to public safety or imminent interruption of services required by law and ‘public safety’ where work cannot reasonably or practicably be performed during regular work hours because of traffic or concern for worker or public safety. For these situations, authorization for after hours work expires after nineteen days and may be renewed as the emergency or public safety situations persist.”
A spokesman for the City’s Department of Law (which represents the Mamdani administration in the lawsuit) referred a request for comment to City Hall. A spokesman for City Hall was not available to comment before deadline.
Among Lower Manhattan residents, the plan to demolish and rebuild MDC (which critics and skeptics argue will cost billions more than its projected budget, an allocation that has jumped from $2.73 to $4.18 billion) has become a flashpoint, largely because of the environmental and health hazards that years of demolition and construction could impose on the surrounding community. Once the project is finished, local community leaders also anticipate decades of crowding on local streets as thousands of staff and support personnel report to the new facility each day.
