You are here: Home/Uncategorized/ The BroadsheetDAILY – 1/12/22 – At 41 River Terrace, Affordability Provisions Extended for Low-Income Residents But Not for Middle-Income Renters
The BroadsheetDAILY – 1/12/22 – At 41 River Terrace, Affordability Provisions Extended for Low-Income Residents But Not for Middle-Income Renters
At 41 River Terrace, Affordability Provisions Extended for Low-Income Residents But Not for Middle-Income Renters
Tribeca Pointe, at 41 River Terrace, in northern Battery Park City
The Battery Park City Authority (BPCA) announced Tuesday that it had reached an agreement to preserve 70 affordable rental apartments in the Tribeca Pointe building through the year 2069. The deal will require that the building owner, Rockrose, continue to offer deeply discounted rents to residents of 70 apartments within the 340-unit structure. These households are set aside for residents earning below either 40 or 50 percent of the “area median income” (AMI). This income bracket currently ranges from $33,440 to $41,800 (for a household consisting of one person), and goes as high as $47,720 to $59,650 (for a household of four).
These terms were set to expire in 2029, under the provisions of the deal governing the building’s original development, in the late 1990s. In exchange for generous tax subsidies and low-interest financing (available because government agencies provided a guarantee on the debt taken out by the developer to fund the project), Rockrose committed to building Tribeca Pointe as an “80/20” building. This meant that one-fifth of the units were offered at very low rents for tenants earning much less than needed to afford market-rate apartments.
When Tribeca Pointe opened in 1999, these requirements translated into $343 or $429 per month in a studio (for those earning up to 40 or 50 percent of AMI, respectively), $368 or $459 for a one-bedroom apartment, and $441 or $451 for a two-bedroom unit. Today, the same formulas (which cap rent at 30 percent of the two income thresholds) restrict rent on a studio apartment, inhabited by one person, to $836 (for a tenant earning below 40 percent of AMI) or $1045 (for a renter earning below 50 percent of AMI).
“This agreement reflects our commitment to preserving affordable housing in Battery Park City while advancing our sustainability goals,” said BPCA president B.J. Jones. “It is an important step in our continued efforts to sustain a vibrant and inclusive community.”
Tuesday’s announcement makes no mention of a second (and much larger) tranche of affordability at Tribeca Pointe, which appears poised to disappear. The same terms that set aside 20 percent of the building’s apartments for low-income tenants also stipulated that residents of the remaining 80 percent of the tower’s units would be protected by rent stabilization. This means that although these tenants would pay market-based rents when they first moved into the building, increases above that baseline would be limited to those allowed by the City’s Rent Guidelines Board for the apartments it regulates, usually limited to less than two percent. This can provide a crucial protection for middle-class tenants, who can generally afford the rents prevailing at the outset of a lease, but are often later forced from their homes by the gyrations of the New York real estate market. For context, the net effective median rent for New York City as a whole rose 22.8 percent in November (compared to the same period a year earlier), and many landlords have responded to the real estate market’s recent bounce back by demanding increases of between 50 and 70 percent.
An annual inventory of rent-stabilized apartments in Lower Manhattan was compiled, as a public service, by Community Board 1 member Tom Goodkind, who was (until his death in 2019) a zealous advocate for housing affordability in Lower Manhattan. This compendium notes that all 340 units in Tribeca Pointe are rent stabilized, and also documents that Rockrose was receiving an annual tax credit of $4.8 million in exchange for this public benefit, which is also scheduled to disappear in 2029. (The same report notes that Rockrose received additional taxpayer support by being allowed to participate in the Liberty Bond program after the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001.) Multiple other sources, including the annual database of rent-stabilized buildings published by the State’s Division of Housing and Community Renewal, attest to Tribeca Pointe being subject to rent stabilization.
The Authority’s announcement of the extension for low-income affordability in 20 percent of the apartments within Tribeca Pointe is silent about renewing rent-stabilization provisions for the remaining 80 percent of households within the building. As such, it appears that these protections will be discontinued as of 2029. In this context, it is possible to view the new terms negotiated between the BPCA and Rockrose as incorporating two, related components: the preservation (beyond 2029) of 70 homes affordable for low-income residents, and the loss (starting in 2029) of 270 homes for middle-class residents.
The disclosure of the BCPA’s deal with Rockrose did not specify what benefits the developer will receive in exchange for extending the affordability protections by an additional 40 years, other than to say, “the agreement will also require annual reporting and commitments to support BPCA’s sustainability and resiliency efforts and goals, set an increasing schedule for ground rent over time, and ensure ongoing capital investment in the building.”
The passage about, “an increasing schedule for ground rent,” is a reference to the exotic nature of property ownership in Battery Park City, where homeowners, landlords, and developers do not own outright the land they occupy, but instead lease the space (through June, 2069), in exchange for yearly payments of ground rent, as well as so-called “payments in lieu of taxes.” Concerns about this arrangement have grown acute in recent years, as more residents have come to realize that, under the current terms of the ground lease, their homes may disappear in 48 years, as ownership of all the real estate in Battery Park City reverts to the Authority. Unless the terms of this lease are modified or extended, for condominium owners, it may mean that their property is effectively confiscated, while renters might face the prospect of eviction. Both owners and tenants could be rendered homeless under this scenario. Neither of these outcomes is a foregone conclusion, but would be subject to the BPCA’s decision about how to move forward.
In recent years, this uncertainty has caused the landlords of many rental buildings in the community either to sell their buildings, or else convert them to condominiums. Rockrose attempted, without success, to do both. In 2014, the developer shopped 41 River Terrace for sale, reportedly asking for $300 million, but found no takers. (This move came on the heels of Rockrose selling a separate Battery Park City rental building, 22 River Terrace for $225 million, to another developer, who evicted all the residents and converted the building to a condominium.) In 2015, Rockrose took preliminary steps toward converting Tribeca Pointe to a condominium, but these plans were complicated by insistence from government regulators that affordability provisions for the low-income apartments be extended through 2069 (the same terms the BPCA has now achieved), and that no residents (either low-income or market rate) could be evicted as a result of the conversion process (apparently in response to the displacement of all residents at 22 River Terrace).
Outlining the terms of the BPCA’s agreement with Rockrose at the November 17 meeting of the BPCA board, Mr. Jones described it as, “a framework that sets ground rent based on building performance, a percentage of adjusted gross income, starting at five percent and increasing to 12 percent over time.”
He added, “we also have protections in place with a schedule of minimum ground rent over the course of the lease. These terms also introduce fees that allow us to take part in the value created through major capital events, such as refinancing, property transfers, and sales. They also include a transaction fee associated with this deal, to be paid to the BPCA in the amount of $3 million, upon execution of the amendment.”
Pamela Frederick, the Authority’s chief financial officer, noted that, “the structure really does shore up the creditworthiness of the BPCA, especially as we go into our next bond issue. One of the questions in the last one is that we would have a series of resets in several of our buildings.” This was a reference to a codicil in the BPCA’s ground leases with various buildings that would “reset” the ground rent at specific dates in the future to a fixed percentage of the fair market value of the underlying land, when appraised as if, “unencumbered.” This is a legal fiction that would direct an appraiser to imagine the land’s value with no ground lease and no building. Such an approach is contrived to maximize (artificially) the land’s value, because the free hand offered by empty acreage is almost always preferred by Manhattan developers.
These resets have come to be viewed as a looming catastrophe by building owners, whether they are rental landlords or the residents of condominiums. In many cases, they would (if implemented) result in ground rent for a given building increasing by millions of dollars (and jumping by several hundred percent) in single stroke. Even the BPCA has acknowledged in recent years that these provisions are unrealistic and uncollectible, because they would inevitably have the effect of forcing buildings into foreclosure and repossession. But the observation by Ms. Fredericks may point to another problem: Bond underwriters have apparently realized that the revenue promised by the reset provisions of the ground leases is unlikely ever to appear on the BPCA’s balance sheet. For this reason, renegotiating leases to incorporate more pragmatic terms (even if they promise less revenue) may have then effect of enhancing the credibility of the BPCA’s promise to reply borrowers in future bond issues.
Noting that, under the terms of this agreement, Tribeca Pointe’s ground rent will increase in the future may obscure the fact that the deal struck by the BPCA almost certainly means that Rockrose’s payments to the Authority will increase by significantly less than they would have under the original terms of the ground lease. In this context, the benefit obtained by Rockrose may amount to many tens of millions of dollars between now and 2069.
An illustrative comparison is by offered a separate affordability deal mentioned in the BPCA’s Tuesday announcement about Tribeca Pointe. In July, 2020, the Authority agreed to revise the ground lease for Gateway Plaza, Battery Park City’s oldest and largest residential complex, to extend a rent protection agreement for approximately 600 households. In exchange for terms that require these tenants to pay more during the coming ten years (but save them from unrestricted market rents), the LeFrak Organization (the owner of Gateway Plaza) received reductions in future ground rent increases worth more than $220 million dollars. This translates into a subsidy of more than $380,000 for each of the 600 households that benefited from this deal. Such a windfall, if given directly to tenants, rather than to their landlord, would have enabled every household in Gateway Plaza to live rent-free for almost five years, or could have paid the entire rent of those 600 households for decades into the future.
BPCA spokesman Nick Sbordone said of the Tribeca Pointe agreement, “we are proud to have delivered for Battery Park City residents by preserving deep affordability in one of New York City’s most expensive neighborhoods for the next nearly half-century. This is the latest step in our continuing work with residential buildings across the neighborhood to directly address concerns about housing costs in Battery Park City.”
Matthew Fenton
What Never Went Up in the First Place, Still Comes Down…
Lower Manhattan Site Purchased for $390 Million Being Shopped for Half-Off
In a story first reported by the Real Deal, the financial distress plaguing property investment firm China Oceanwide Holdings (itself part of the wider contagion surrounding Shenzhen-based real estate firm, Evergrande) has led to a fire-sale price for a trophy Lower Manhattan parcel.
The company purchased 80 South Street (located between John Street and Maiden Lane) from the Howard Hughes Corporation in 2016 for $390 million. This transaction included a companion site, at 163 Front Street, that shares a mid-block border with 80 South Street. The combined parcel, plus air rights from nearby lots purchased and assembled by Howard Hughes, gave China Oceanwide the right to build a tower with a height of more than 1,400 feet, enclosing more than one million square feet of interior space. To read more…
‘I Don’t Believe in Building New Jails’
New Council Member on Development and Diversity, Prison Plans and Affordability
Newly inaugurated City Council member Christopher Marte reflected on the Lower Manhattan district he now represents, and some of the issues facing the community, in a January 4 interview with WNYC radio.
“We have some of the wealthiest [residents] in Battery Park City and Tribeca,” Mr. Marte told host Brian Lehrer, “but we have people who live beneath or close to the poverty line, whether it’s in the Smith houses, or people who live in rent-stabilized apartments. And they come from all over the world. There are the Fujianese community on East Broadway, and Dominicans, Puerto Ricans.”
We can help you easily declutter and organize your overstuffed closets, jammed bookcases, bursting cabinets and drawers, and enormous stacks of paper to put your home in “company is coming” condition.
Providing Companion and Home Health Aide Care to clients with dementia.Help with grooming, dressing and wheelchair assistance. Able to escort client to parks and engage in conversations of desired topics and interests of client. Reliable & Honest
78 year old refined intellectual gentleman having a passion for cruises and travel seeking a male or female caregiver/companion in exchange for all expense paid venture on the ocean. Only requirement is relationship comfort between us and ability to help with physical care regarding the limitations and restrictions of COPD.
Join China expert and diplomat Nicholas Platt, who will share the story of the Philadelphia Orchestra’s 1973 trip to China at Richard Nixon’s behest. Platt, who was the Foreign Service Control Officer for that historic visit, handled the negotiations—with plenty of challenges on both the American and the Chinese sides.
6PM
Community Board 1 Landmarks & Preservation Committee
In this lecture, Desmarais will discuss recent discoveries about the Count de Rochambeau’s army that counter popular assumptions—focusing primarily on the recently published diary of the Count de Lauberdière, which includes details that are not covered in any other French diaries. Serving as an aide-de-camp on General Rochambeau’s staff, the young and well-educated Lauberdière provided a unique perspective of the war, including descriptions of the French army’s camp in Newport, the long march to Yorktown, the siege and capture, and a fascinating examination of the people and their distinctive colonial culture. This lecture will take place via Zoom. Free
The pandemic has highlighted health inequities that disproportionately impact vulnerable populations by creating and exacerbating poverty and leading to decreased life expectancy throughout the world. Join the Rev. Phillip Jackson as he speaks to leaders and experts, exploring how people of faith can advocate for those most affected by these inequities. Free
Online film streaming. Part concert film and part comedy, Rock ‘n’ Roll High School (1979, Allan Arkush) is about a student who leads a rock rebellion against the school administration with help from the Ramones. Registration required. Free
During the last year of her life, Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg sat down with Moment editor-in-chief Nadine Epstein to discuss the Jewish women she found inspiring. In Epstein’s new intergenerational book RBG’s Brave and Brilliant Women: 33 Jewish Women to Inspire Everyone, she profiles the women Ginsburg identified and reflects on each of their stories. The trailblazers in the book, like Ginsburg herself, each fought to forge a better world rather than accepting it as it was. Join the Museum of Jewish Heritage and Moment for a program celebrating RBG’s Brave and Brilliant Women, featuring Epstein in conversation with author and journalist Abigail Pogrebin.Free; suggested $10 donation
An Aversion to Immersion
SLA Okays New Performance Venue in FiDi, Despite Opposition from Local Leaders
Over the objections of Community Board 1 (CB1) and hundreds of local residents, the State Liquor Authority (SLA) has approved the application for a license to serve alcohol by Submursive, a production company that wants to open a 100,000-square-foot performance venue, spread across seven floors of 20 Exchange Place, in the Financial District.
A Onetime Haunt of Ponies, Plutocrats, and Club Rats Will Get a Room with a View
Tribeca will soon have a new (albeit invisible) penthouse apartment, if the City’s Landmarks Preservation Commission is guided by the advice of Community Board 1. At its November meeting, the Board recommended that the LPC give its okay to a proposal to add a rooftop structure to 157 Hudson Street, located between Laight and Hubert Streets, opposite the Holland Tunnel rotary.
The T-shaped building has a storied history. Erected in 1867, it was originally designed to serve as a multi-story stable for the hundreds of draft horses kept at the ready by the newly founded American Express Company. This was an era when the firm was primarily engaged in the secure shipment of valuable cargo, almost a century before the invention of credit cards. To read more…
Lenders Who Fronted Millions to Operators of Pier A Allege Fraud
Investors who lent more than $16 million to the operators behind the shuttered restaurant at Pier A, on Battery Park City’s southern border allege that the borrowers, “used a fraudulent scheme to squeeze out of the Project all the fees and distributions for themselves that they could before shutting the doors.”
In a development first reported by property industry newsletter the Real Deal, the lenders (Tribeca-based New York City Waterfront Development Fund II) filed suit in Manhattan Supreme Court in November, seeking the return of $16.5 million (the original amount of the 2011 loan, none of which has been repaid), along with $2.63 million in accrued interest, plus attorney’s fees and court costs.
The defendants in this action are a partnership between the Poulakakos restaurant family (who operate numerous Lower Manhattan eateries) and the Dermot Company (a developer of garden apartment complexes around the United States that more recently branched out to New York projects, such as the conversion of Brooklyn’s landmarked Williamsburgh Savings Bank tower into condominium residences). To read more…
Lower Manhattan Greenmarkets
Tribeca Greenmarket
Greenwich Street & Chambers Street
Every Wednesday & Saturday, 8am-3pm
Food Scrap Collection: Saturdays, 8am-1pm
Open Saturdays and Wednesdays year round
Bowling Green Greenmarket
Green Greenmarket at Bowling Green
Broadway & Whitehall St
Open Tuesday and Thursdays, year-round
Market Hours: 8:00 a.m. – 5:00 p.m.
Compost Program: 8 a.m. – 11 a.m.
The Bowling Green Greenmarket brings fresh offerings from local farms to Lower Manhattan’s historic Bowling Green plaza. Twice a week year-round stop by to load up on the season’s freshest fruit, crisp vegetables, beautiful plants, and freshly baked loaves of bread, quiches, and pot pies.
Fulton Street cobblestones between South and Front Sts. across from McNally Jackson Bookstore.
Locally grown produce from Rogowski Farm, Breezy Hill Orchard, and other farmers and small-batch specialty food products, sold directly by their producers. Producers vary from week to week.
SNAP/EBT/P-EBT, Debit/Credit, and Farmers Market Nutrition Program checks accepted at all farmers markets.
TODAY IN HISTORY
January 12
Upon the death of her husband Thaddeus Caraway, Hattie Caraway filled the vacancy and thereby became the second woman to serve in the Senate. Although considered a long shot, she was the first woman to be elected when she ran in the 1932 general election. Senator Hattie Caraway of Arkansas credit: Library of Congress
1866 – The Royal Aeronautical Society is formed in London.
1908 – A long-distance radio message is sent from the Eiffel Tower for the first time.
1932 – Hattie Caraway becomes the first woman elected to the United States Senate.
1967 – Dr. James Bedford becomes the first person to be cryonically preservedwith intent of future resuscitation.
1971 – The Harrisburg Seven: Rev. Philip Berrigan and five other activists are indicted on charges of conspiring to kidnap Henry Kissinger and of plotting to blow up the heating tunnels of federal buildings in Washington, D.C.
1998 – Nineteen European nations agree to forbid human cloning.
2004 – The world’s largest ocean liner, RMS Queen Mary 2, makes its maiden voyage.
2010 – An earthquake in Haiti occurs, killing over 100,000 people and destroying much of the capital Port-au-Prince.
The Queen Mary 2 tied up in Red Hook Brooklyn.
Births
1822 – Étienne Lenoir, Belgian engineer, designed the internal combustion engine (d. 1900)
1856 – John Singer Sargent, American painter and academic (d. 1925)
1944 – Joe Frazier, American boxer (d. 2011)
Deaths
1519 – Maximilian I, Holy Roman Emperor (b. 1459)
1665 – Pierre de Fermat, French mathematician and lawyer (b. 1601)
1976 – Agatha Christie, English crime novelist, short story writer, and playwright (b. 1890)[37]
1988 – Piero Taruffi, Italian racing driver and motorcycle racer (b. 1906)
1997 – Charles Brenton Huggins, Canadian-American physician and physiologist, Nobel Prize laureate (b. 1901)
2002 – Cyrus Vance, American lawyer and politician, 57th U.S. Secretary of State (b. 1917)
Credit: Wikipedia and other internet and non-internet sources
This article has lots of nonsense. First of all the BPC authority allows the landlords on their land to get away with murder. The Tribeca Pointe building has received a gross amount of tax abatements over the last 20+ years but was never affordable for middle class, unless you believe that $7000-$9000. a month for a 2 bedroom is affordable middle class housing. They have collected well above market rate rents since opening and paid no tax! Hello BPC Authority and elected officials, stop pretending you’re doing something for the masses when you are doing nothing.. BPC is patting themselves on the back for making an agreement with Rockrose to give them 100’s of millions more in tax abatements in order to keep what is less than 70 apartments for low income. The reality is that a large number of the people in those apartments live elsewhere and make a mint putting those low rent apartments on Air B&B or using them as a pied-a-Terre. If BPC or the Elected officials cared about affordable housing there would be more of it and what Rockrose does at their Tribeca Pointe building should have been investigated before doling our more millions to the billionaire landlord who collects a mint in rents in that building already.
This article has lots of nonsense. First of all the BPC authority allows the landlords on their land to get away with murder. The Tribeca Pointe building has received a gross amount of tax abatements over the last 20+ years but was never affordable for middle class, unless you believe that $7000-$9000. a month for a 2 bedroom is affordable middle class housing. They have collected well above market rate rents since opening and paid no tax! Hello BPC Authority and elected officials, stop pretending you’re doing something for the masses when you are doing nothing.. BPC is patting themselves on the back for making an agreement with Rockrose to give them 100’s of millions more in tax abatements in order to keep what is less than 70 apartments for low income. The reality is that a large number of the people in those apartments live elsewhere and make a mint putting those low rent apartments on Air B&B or using them as a pied-a-Terre. If BPC or the Elected officials cared about affordable housing there would be more of it and what Rockrose does at their Tribeca Pointe building should have been investigated before doling our more millions to the billionaire landlord who collects a mint in rents in that building already.